Last year, we ordered the McAllister sweater for our son and loved it. It was soft and fit well. This year, he wanted the fall pumpkin sweater. We were extremely disappointed in the quality. The size seems too small and the material is not as soft. We ordered the exact same size as last year (12). Attached is a picture of the two shirts side by side. Unfortunately, it was a gift, so it was past the 30 day return before we opened it and noticed the drastic size difference. In fairness, we did not reach out to customer service for that reason. Below is a picture of the two shirts side by side. The McAllister is from last year and the fall is from this year. The McAllister has been washed and worn many times as it is one of my son's favorite shirts. The fall sweater was washed once in cold water then hung to dry in hopes that it would stretch out. It did not.